Is Magma's Reign Over?

So which is better ?

Spellbook? Magma? Golden? Silver?


This is the summary. (Which you can do for yourself of course =P)

No weapon, just bases and charm (best charm)



Spell book base + Spellbook charm
----------------------------------

1000 raw power

power bonus = 22%

attr= 5

luck 7

Fresh







Silver T + Champion charm
-------------------------

800 raw power

15% power bonus

Attr = 5%

Luck 13

Very Fresh





Golden T + Champion Charm
------------------------

900 raw power

20% power bonus

Attr 10%

Luck 15

Extremely Fresh




Magma + Champion Charm
-----------------------

700 raw power

13% Power bonus

Attr = 5%

Luck = 13

Insanely Stale





++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++



So Magma is outclassed by Silver and Golden IF the champion charm is armed. If you are using a specialised cheese, say Crunchy, then Magma is still better.


I actually did a comparison to compare Spellbook versus Golden and Silver if Spellbook charm is used =)


I have always knowned the Spellbook charm is a bit of a sleeper (well at least people don't seem too wowed by it). It has served me well. But in the recent tournament, its use was pretty good. I switched from Champion charm to Spellbook charm (using SBB) and it seemed to be equivalent to the champion charm minimally.

In fact I am now farming it =D as being the power supporter, I like it quite abit (it also does help that trap effectiveness was a significant variable)

Golden cuts it pretty close, to the point that even when biasing power, I might use golden (besides Champion Charms are far easier to get). But against Silver i will still use SBB + Spellbook Charm



So is Magma outclassed? If you arm the Champion charms yes, if not then Golden is like a better Spellbook Base (w/o Spellbook charm) and Silver is like a lesser Spellbook Base (w/o Spellbook charm).